I purchased the waterproof version of this new L'oreal mascara. I am pretty funny about mascara and usually tend to stick with one when I find one I really like. I actually sniff the mascara and can usually tell whether or not I'm going to like it just by the smell. Weird, I know! =)
This mascara did leave my lashes looking fuller and didn't leave them completely stiff. After 9 hours of wear, I had no flaking. I was able to build my lashes up without having to redip the wand, so I was using less product than usual.
If you like very defined lashes, then this probably won't be your favorite mascara but if you like full BIG lashes give this one a try.